
The treatment of hepatobiliary diseases has made big strides. New medicines, immunotherapy, and better tests have helped patients a lot.
Conditions like primary biliary cholangitis are now easier to handle. This is an autoimmune condition that can cause biliary cirrhosis and liver disease. The EASL Congress 2025 showed off new treatments, like efruxifermin. It looks promising for fixing cirrhosis caused by metabolic problems.
These new steps mark a big change in how we care for patients. They bring hope for better treatment of liver disease and other related issues.
Key Takeaways
- Advancements in medications and immunotherapy are improving outcomes for hepatobiliary diseases.
- Primary biliary cholangitis is being managed more effectively with new treatments.
- EASL Congress 2025 highlighted promising new therapies, including efruxifermin.
- Reversal of cirrhosis due to MASH is now possible with certain treatments.
- Improved diagnostics are contributing to better patient care.
The Hepatobiliary System: Structure and Function
It’s important to know how the hepatobiliary system works. This system includes the liver, gallbladder, and bile ducts. It’s key for digestion and breaking down nutrients.
Anatomy of Liver, Gallbladder, and Bile Ducts
The liver is the biggest organ inside us. It’s split into parts and makes bile, a fluid that helps with fat digestion. The gallbladder holds this bile until it’s needed. It then goes into the bile ducts and into the small intestine.
The liver’s structure helps it clean and process things. The gallbladder concentrates bile for better digestion. This teamwork is essential for our health.
Physiological Roles in Digestion and Metabolism
The hepatobiliary system is vital for digestion and metabolism. The liver breaks down nutrients and cleanses toxins. It also makes proteins for blood clotting and more.
Bile from the liver and gallbladder helps digest fats. It also helps us absorb vitamins that need fats to work.
|
Organ |
Function |
|---|---|
|
Liver |
Metabolism, Detoxification, Bile Production |
|
Gallbladder |
Bile Storage and Concentration |
|
Bile Ducts |
Bile Transport to Small Intestine |
Common Pathological Processes
Many diseases can harm the hepatobiliary system. These include infections, autoimmune diseases, and cancers. Conditions like cholangitis and cholecystitis are inflammation of the bile ducts and gallbladder.
Knowing about these diseases helps us treat them better. The system’s problems can cause a lot of suffering. So, understanding it well is very important.
Understanding PBC (Primary Biliary Cholangitis)

Primary biliary cholangitis is a rare disease where the bile ducts in the liver get destroyed. This condition causes cholestasis, which is when bile flow stops. Over time, this can damage the liver.
Pathophysiology and Disease Progression
PBC is caused by the immune system attacking the bile ducts in the liver. This attack reduces bile duct function. It leads to bile acids building up in the liver, causing inflammation and scarring.
Key aspects of PBC progression include:
- Chronic inflammation of the bile ducts
- Gradual destruction of bile ducts
- Potential progression to cirrhosis
- Increased risk of liver failure
Risk Factors and Epidemiology
Studies have found that genetics and environment play a role in PBC. Most people with PBC are women. The ratio of women to men with the disease is between 9:1 and 22:1.
|
Risk Factor |
Description |
|---|---|
|
Genetic Predisposition |
Family history of PBC or other autoimmune diseases |
|
Environmental Triggers |
Exposure to certain chemicals or infections |
|
Gender |
Predominantly affects women |
Clinical Presentation and Symptoms
PBC symptoms can vary a lot. Common signs include feeling tired, itching, and jaundice. Some people may not show symptoms for years, while others may get sick faster.
Common symptoms of PBC include:
- Fatigue
- Pruritus (itching)
- Jaundice
- Xanthelasmata (fatty deposits around the eyes)
Diagnostic Approaches for Hepatobiliary Conditions

Accurate diagnosis of hepatobiliary conditions is key to effective treatment. Several methods are used, including lab tests, imaging, and histopathology.
Laboratory Biomarkers and Serological Tests
Laboratory biomarkers are essential for diagnosing liver diseases. Liver enzymes like ALT and AST show liver damage. Tests for ALP and GGT check for cholestasis.
Serological tests help find autoimmune and infectious causes. For example, AMA is found in Primary Biliary Cholangitis, and ANA in autoimmune hepatitis.
- Liver enzymes (ALT, AST)
- Bilirubin levels
- ALP and GGT for cholestasis
- Serological markers for autoimmune hepatitis
Advanced Imaging Techniques
Advanced imaging is vital for diagnosing and tracking liver diseases. Ultrasound is often the first choice because it’s non-invasive and can spot gallstones and liver issues.
Computed Tomography (CT) and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) give detailed liver and bile duct images. Magnetic Resonance Cholangiopancreatography (MRCP) is great for bile duct views.
- Ultrasound for initial assessment
- CT scans for detailed liver imaging
- MRI and MRCP for biliary tree visualization
Histopathological Assessment
Histopathology is the top method for diagnosing many liver diseases. Liver biopsy gives detailed info on damage, inflammation, and fibrosis.
In PBC, histology helps track disease progress and treatment. It also helps in autoimmune hepatitis and steatohepatitis to assess severity and treatment response.
- Liver biopsy for histological examination
- Assessment of fibrosis and inflammation
- Staging of liver disease
First-Line Treatments for PBC
PBC management mainly uses Ursodeoxycholic Acid (UDCA) as a first choice. UDCA is known for improving liver function and slowing disease progress in Primary Biliary Cholangitis patients.
Ursodeoxycholic Acid (UDCA): Mechanism and Efficacy
UDCA improves bile flow and lowers toxic bile acids in the liver. It works by changing the immune response and reducing inflammation. This makes it effective for treating PBC, improving liver function tests, and slowing disease progress.
Monitoring Treatment Response
It’s important to watch how UDCA works in PBC patients. Checking liver function tests like alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and bilirubin helps see if UDCA is working. Patients with lower ALP levels do better. Regular follow-up is key to adjust treatment plans as needed.
Managing UDCA-Refractory Cases
Some patients don’t get better with UDCA, known as UDCA-refractory PBC. For these cases, other treatments are considered. Second-line therapies, like Obeticholic Acid, might be used to help. Handling these cases needs a detailed plan, looking at disease progress and new treatments.
Dealing with PBC is complex and needs a personalized treatment plan. Knowing how UDCA works and how to handle treatment responses and hard cases helps doctors improve patient care.
Second-Line and Emerging Therapies for PBC
<SEP-7096_image_4>
PBC treatment has grown with new therapies. These offer hope to those not helped by usual treatments. As we learn more about PBC, we find new ways to help patients.
Obeticholic Acid and FXR Agonists
Obeticholic acid is a new treatment for PBC. It works by turning on FXR, which helps control bile acids. This can lessen liver damage. Studies show it helps patients not helped by UDCA.
Key Benefits of Obeticholic Acid:
- Enhanced bile acid homeostasis
- Anti-inflammatory and antifibrotic effects
- Improved liver biochemistry
Bezafibrate and PPAR Agonists
Bezafibrate is another promising treatment for PBC. It’s used with UDCA. Bezafibrate helps reduce inflammation and fibrosis, improving liver health.
“The combination of bezafibrate and UDCA has been shown to improve liver biochemistry and reduce symptoms in PBC patients, making it a promising treatment.”
Novel Therapeutic Targets in Clinical Trials
New research is looking at more ways to treat PBC. This includes more FXR and PPAR agonists, and drugs targeting different disease pathways. These new treatments aim to give more options for PBC patients.
|
Therapeutic Agent |
Mechanism of Action |
Clinical Status |
|---|---|---|
|
Obeticholic Acid |
FXR Agonist |
Approved for second-line therapy |
|
Bezafibrate |
PPAR Agonist |
In clinical trials for PBC |
|
Nivolumab |
Checkpoint Inhibitor |
In trials for advanced PBC |
New treatments for PBC are a big step forward. As we learn more, we’ll find even better ways to help patients. This means better care for those with PBC.
Management of Viral Hepatitis
<SEP-7096_image_5>
Managing viral hepatitis well is key to avoiding liver damage and better health outcomes. Thanks to new antiviral treatments, the fight against viral hepatitis has made big strides. These new therapies offer high cure rates and better chances for patients.
Antiviral Therapies for Hepatitis B
Hepatitis B is a big health issue worldwide. But, antiviral treatments are now the main treatment. Nucleos(t)ide analogs like tenofovir and entecavir are top choices. They work well to stop the virus from spreading.
Choosing the right treatment depends on many things. This includes the patient’s health, how much virus is present, and if there’s drug resistance. It’s important to keep an eye on how the treatment is working and make changes if needed.
Direct-Acting Antivirals for Hepatitis C
The introduction of direct-acting antivirals (DAAs) has changed hepatitis C treatment. DAAs target specific virus proteins, making treatment very effective. This has led to cure rates over 95% for many patients.
Doctors tailor treatment plans based on the virus type, past treatments, and liver health. DAAs are easy to take, often just one or two pills a day for 8-12 weeks. This makes it easier for patients to stick to their treatment.
Functional Cure Strategies in Late-Stage Trials
Researchers are also working on a functional cure for hepatitis B. This means patients could stop treatment and stay virus-free. New drugs like capsid inhibitors and RNA interference are being tested in late-stage trials.
These new ideas could change how we treat viral hepatitis. They might lead to shorter treatments and better results for patients.
Treating Metabolic Dysfunction-Associated Steatohepatitis (MASH)
MASH is a serious liver condition linked to metabolic issues. It needs careful treatment to stop it from getting worse. This is key to avoid liver damage and failure.
Lifestyle Interventions and Weight Management
Changing your lifestyle is the first step in treating MASH. Weight loss is very helpful. It can make your liver healthier and reduce inflammation.
- Dietary changes: Eating fewer calories and a balanced diet can help manage weight and improve metabolic health.
- Physical activity: Regular exercise helps with weight loss. It also makes your body more sensitive to insulin and lowers liver fat.
Behavioral therapy helps patients stick to these lifestyle changes. This makes the treatment plan more effective.
Pharmacological Approaches
For those who need more help, there are medicines being tested. These include:
- Insulin sensitizers: Drugs like pioglitazone help improve insulin resistance, a big factor in MASH.
- Antioxidants: Vitamin E can lessen liver inflammation in some cases.
- Anti-obesity medications: Some drugs help with weight loss, which benefits MASH patients.
Efruxifermin: Reversing Cirrhosis in MASH
Efruxifermin is a new medicine that looks promising. It’s a FGF21 analog that improves insulin sensitivity, lowers liver fat, and helps reverse fibrosis.
The discovery of efruxifermin is a big step forward in treating MASH. It gives hope to those with severe disease.
Therapeutic Strategies for Autoimmune Hepatitis
Autoimmune hepatitis needs careful treatment with drugs that calm the immune system. The main goal is to stop the liver from getting worse. This helps patients live better lives.
Corticosteroids and Immunosuppressants
Corticosteroids and immunosuppressants are key in treating autoimmune hepatitis. Corticosteroids, like prednisone, start by reducing inflammation. Then, drugs like azathioprine help keep the liver calm and let corticosteroids be reduced.
Using both corticosteroids and immunosuppressants helps a lot. Research shows it improves liver health and lab results.
Maintenance Therapy Protocols
After the liver gets better, maintenance therapy is needed to keep it that way. This usually means taking immunosuppressants, like azathioprine. Doctors watch liver health closely and adjust treatment as needed.
Every patient’s treatment plan is different. Doctors change plans if side effects happen or if treatment stops working.
Management of Treatment-Resistant Cases
If standard treatments don’t work or cause too many side effects, new options are tried. Alternative immunosuppressants or biologic agents might be used. Mycophenolate mofetil and tacrolimus are examples of drugs that can help.
Dealing with treatment-resistant autoimmune hepatitis needs a team effort. Hepatologists and other experts work together to find the best treatment for each patient.
Gallstone Disease: Medical and Surgical Approaches
Gallstone disease treatment has changed a lot. It now includes many medical and surgical methods. This condition is common and affects many people around the world. So, finding good treatments is very important.
Medical Dissolution Therapy
Medical dissolution therapy is a non-invasive way to treat small, radiolucent gallstones. It uses ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA) to dissolve some gallstones. But, how well it works depends on the stone’s size and type.
This treatment isn’t right for everyone. The size, number, and type of stones, plus the patient’s health, play a big role. Doctors decide if it’s a good choice based on these factors.
Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy
Laparoscopic cholecystectomy is a common surgery for gallstones. It removes the gallbladder through small cuts. This means less pain and a quicker recovery than open surgery.
This surgery has many benefits. It lowers the risk of problems, shortens hospital stays, and lets people get back to their lives faster. But, surgery is only for those who really need it, based on their symptoms and health.
Endoscopic Management of Bile Duct Stones
Endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) is key for bile duct stones. It removes stones from the bile duct. This stops blockages and prevents serious infections like cholangitis.
For those with bile duct stones, endoscopic management is a good option. It’s less invasive than surgery. The success of ERCP depends on the doctor’s skill and the stone’s characteristics.
Treatment of Biliary Tract Disorders
Biliary tract disorders, like primary sclerosing cholangitis, need careful treatment. These conditions can really affect a patient’s quality of life. A thorough treatment plan is essential.
Primary Sclerosing Cholangitis Management
Primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC) is a chronic liver disease. It causes inflammation and fibrosis in the bile ducts. The goal in managing PSC is to slow down the disease and ease symptoms.
Key management strategies for PSC include:
- Monitoring liver function and bile duct health
- Managing symptoms such as pruritus and fatigue
- Addressing complications like dominant strictures
- Considering liver transplantation in advanced cases
|
Management Approach |
Description |
Benefits |
|---|---|---|
|
Ursodeoxycholic Acid (UDCA) |
Used to improve bile flow and reduce liver inflammation |
May slow disease progression |
|
Endoscopic Intervention |
Procedures like ERCP to manage strictures and stones |
Relieves obstruction, improves symptoms |
|
Liver Transplantation |
Reserved for advanced PSC with significant liver damage |
Can be life-saving, restores liver function |
Interventions for Biliary Strictures
Biliary strictures are common in PSC and need quick treatment to avoid liver damage. Endoscopic methods are often used to treat these strictures.
Endoscopic Retrograde Cholangiopancreatography (ERCP)
ERCP is a key tool for diagnosing and treating biliary strictures and other disorders. It lets doctors see the bile ducts directly and perform treatments like stenting and dilation.
Benefits of ERCP include:
- Accurate diagnosis of biliary pathology
- Effective management of strictures and stones
- Minimally invasive, reducing recovery time
Surgical Interventions in Hepatobiliary Disease
New surgical techniques have made a big difference for people with liver and bile duct diseases. These advances offer hope and new ways to treat these conditions. Each patient gets a treatment plan that fits their needs.
Liver Resection Techniques
Liver resection is a surgery that removes part of the liver with disease. Anatomical resections follow the liver’s segmental anatomy. Non-anatomical resections are for lesions that don’t fit into segments.
The right technique depends on the lesion’s location, size, and the liver’s function. Better imaging and surgery methods have made liver resection safer and more effective.
|
Type of Resection |
Description |
Indications |
|---|---|---|
|
Anatomical Resection |
Follows segmental liver anatomy |
Lesions within defined segments |
|
Non-Anatomical Resection |
For lesions not conforming to segments |
Superficial or irregular lesions |
Liver Transplantation: Indications and Outcomes
Liver transplantation is a lifesaving option for those with severe liver disease or liver cancer. The decision to transplant depends on the liver’s condition and complications.
Indications for liver transplantation include cirrhosis, acute liver failure, and certain metabolic disorders. Thanks to better immunosuppression and surgery, outcomes have greatly improved.
Minimally Invasive Hepatobiliary Surgery
Minimally invasive surgery has changed hepatobiliary surgery for the better. It offers less recovery time and less pain. Techniques include laparoscopic and robotic-assisted surgery.
These approaches are used for many procedures, like cholecystectomy and liver resection. The choice depends on the procedure, patient factors, and the surgeon’s skills.
- Laparoscopic cholecystectomy for gallbladder disease
- Robotic-assisted liver resection for selected cases
Immunotherapy Advances for Hepatocellular Carcinoma
Immunotherapy has changed how we treat hepatocellular carcinoma, giving new hope to those with advanced disease. It uses the body’s immune system to attack cancer. This makes treatment more targeted and possibly more effective.
Checkpoint Inhibitors: Nivolumab and Ipilimumab
Checkpoint inhibitors are key in immunotherapy for hepatocellular carcinoma. Nivolumab and Ipilimumab are leading the way. Nivolumab blocks the PD-1 checkpoint, and Ipilimumab targets CTLA-4. Together, they boost the immune system’s fight against cancer.
The combination of Nivolumab and Ipilimumab has been tested in many trials. It has shown better results for patients with advanced hepatocellular carcinoma. This combo works best for those who haven’t responded to other treatments.
CheckMate9DW Trial: Survival Benefits
The CheckMate9DW trial was a major study on Nivolumab and Ipilimumab for advanced hepatocellular carcinoma. It found survival benefits. Patients lived longer than those on standard treatments.
This trial’s results are key in showing immunotherapy’s role in treating hepatocellular carcinoma. It sets a new standard for advanced disease treatment.
Combination Approaches with Targeted Therapies
Researchers are also looking into combining checkpoint inhibitors with targeted therapies. These combos aim to make immunotherapy work better. They target specific cancer growth pathways.
Studies are ongoing to find the best combinations and sequences. The goal is to better patient outcomes and offer more treatment options for hepatocellular carcinoma.
Innovative Treatments in the Hepatobiliary Pipeline
Medical research is leading to new treatments for liver and bile duct diseases. These new methods aim to better help patients. They promise to change how we manage these conditions.
Gene Therapy Approaches
Gene therapy is a new hope for treating liver and bile duct diseases. It targets the genetic causes of these conditions. This could lead to long-term or even permanent cures.
Researchers are using gene editing, like CRISPR/Cas9, to fix genetic problems. This could fix liver and bile duct issues.
Gene therapy has big benefits. It can treat the root cause of diseases, not just the symptoms. But, there are challenges like finding safe ways to deliver the therapy.
Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine
Stem cell therapy and regenerative medicine are also being studied. They aim to fix or replace damaged liver and bile duct tissues. This uses stem cells or cells that can grow into different types of cells.
Regenerative medicine could help patients with severe liver disease. It’s focused on making stem cells work better. This could help the liver function again.
Precision Medicine and Biomarker-Guided Therapy
Precision medicine is changing how we treat liver and bile duct diseases. It tailors treatments to each patient’s unique genetic and molecular profile. Biomarker-guided therapy is a key part of this, helping doctors choose the best treatments.
Biomarkers help doctors diagnose and track diseases more accurately. This leads to personalized treatment plans. As research grows, these methods will likely improve patient outcomes a lot.
Nutritional and Lifestyle Support for Hepatobiliary Patients
Managing hepatobiliary diseases needs a full plan. This includes good nutrition and lifestyle changes. A balanced diet and lifestyle tweaks can really help patients.
Evidence-Based Dietary Recommendations
Eating lots of fruits, veggies, and whole grains is good for the liver. Foods rich in antioxidants can lower liver inflammation. A study in the Journal of Hepatology shows a Mediterranean diet helps liver health.
“Dietary interventions play a key role in managing liver diseases. A personalized diet can greatly improve patient outcomes.”
Every patient’s nutritional needs are different. For example, those with cirrhosis might need a special diet to manage their condition well.
Physical Activity Guidelines
Staying active is key for health, and it helps liver patients too. Doing moderate exercise, like walking or cycling, for 150 minutes a week can boost liver function and overall health.
A study in the Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology shows exercise can cut liver fat and inflammation in NAFLD patients.
Avoiding Hepatotoxins and Medication Management
Hepatobiliary patients must steer clear of liver-damaging substances, or hepatotoxins. Staying away from alcohol and certain meds is vital. They should work with their doctor to manage their meds and avoid liver harm.
Managing meds means watching and adjusting them to avoid liver damage. Patients should know the risks of over-the-counter meds and herbal supplements.
By living a healthy lifestyle and following dietary advice, patients with hepatobiliary diseases can enhance their quality of life and disease outcomes.
Managing Complications of Advanced Liver Disease
It’s key to manage complications of advanced liver disease to better patient outcomes and quality of life. Advanced liver disease can cause severe issues like portal hypertension, ascites, hepatorenal syndrome, and hepatic encephalopathy.
Portal Hypertension Interventions
Portal hypertension is a big problem in advanced liver disease, where the portal vein’s pressure goes up. To manage it, we use:
- Beta-blockers: Propranolol and nadolol help lower the portal pressure.
- Endoscopic Therapy: This includes variceal ligation and sclerotherapy to stop bleeding.
- Transjugular Intrahepatic Portosystemic Shunt (TIPS): TIPS is a procedure that makes a shunt between the hepatic vein and the portal vein to reduce pressure.
Treatment of Ascites and Hepatorenal Syndrome
Ascites and hepatorenal syndrome are serious issues that need quick action.
- Ascites Management: Treatment includes sodium restriction, diuretics like spironolactone and furosemide, and paracentesis for big amounts of fluid.
- Hepatorenal Syndrome Treatment: This involves vasoconstrictors like terlipressin with albumin, and sometimes liver transplant.
Hepatic Encephalopathy Management
Hepatic encephalopathy is a brain and behavior problem from advanced liver disease. Treatment includes:
- Lactulose: The main treatment to lower ammonia levels.
- Rifaximin: An antibiotic to prevent it from coming back.
- Dietary Modifications: Eating less protein and making other diet changes.
- Liver Transplantation: An option for some patients.
Handling these complications well needs a team effort. This team includes hepatologists, radiologists, and other experts. Their work helps improve patient outcomes and quality of life.
The Economic Landscape of Hepatobiliary Treatment
The world of hepatobiliary treatment is growing fast. The hepatobiliary treatment market is expanding because of more liver diseases, better treatments, and higher healthcare costs.
Conclusion: Future Directions in Hepatobiliary Disease Management
The future of treating liver and bile duct diseases looks bright. This is thanks to ongoing research and new treatments. These advancements will help improve care for those with these conditions.
Understanding liver and bile duct diseases is key to better treatment. This includes conditions like Primary Biliary Cholangitis (PBC), viral hepatitis, and Metabolic Dysfunction-Associated Steatohepatitis (MASH). New treatments like Obeticholic Acid and gene therapy are changing how we treat these diseases.
Future treatments will be more tailored to each patient. This will involve new therapies and technologies. It’s important to keep investing in research to help more people and make treatments available worldwide.
FAQ
What is Primary Biliary Cholangitis (PBC)?
Primary Biliary Cholangitis (PBC) is a chronic disease of the liver. It causes damage to the bile ducts, leading to liver problems and possibly cirrhosis.
What are the symptoms of PBC?
Symptoms of PBC include feeling very tired, itching, jaundice, and pain in the right upper abdomen. Some people may not show symptoms early on.
How is PBC diagnosed?
Doctors use tests like liver function tests and antimitochondrial antibody tests to diagnose PBC. They might also do imaging studies or a liver biopsy to check the damage.
What is the first-line treatment for PBC?
The main treatment for PBC is Ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA). It helps by improving bile flow and reducing inflammation in the liver.
What are the treatment options for UDCA-refractory PBC?
For those not helped by UDCA, treatments like obeticholic acid and bezafibrate are used. New treatments are being tested in clinical trials.
How is viral hepatitis managed?
Viral hepatitis is treated with antiviral drugs. For hepatitis C, direct-acting antivirals are used. For hepatitis B, nucleos(t)ide analogues are prescribed. Researchers are also looking into functional cure strategies.
What lifestyle changes can help manage hepatobiliary diseases?
To manage liver diseases, eat a healthy diet and stay active. Avoid harmful substances like alcohol and certain medications. Keeping a healthy weight also helps reduce liver strain.
What are the surgical options for hepatobiliary diseases?
Surgery can include removing part of the liver for tumors, transplanting a new liver, or minimally invasive procedures for gallstones.
What is the role of immunotherapy in hepatocellular carcinoma?
Immunotherapy, like nivolumab and ipilimumab, boosts the immune system to fight liver cancer cells. It has shown to be effective in treating the disease.
What are the emerging therapies for hepatobiliary diseases?
New treatments include gene therapy, stem cell and regenerative medicine, and personalized medicine. These are tailored to each patient’s needs and disease.
How do economic factors impact access to hepatobiliary treatment?
The market for treating liver diseases is growing. But, not everyone can get the care they need, mainly in low-income countries. This is due to cost, lack of healthcare, and treatment availability.
National Center for Biotechnology Information. Evidence-Based Medical Insight. Retrieved from
References
National Center for Biotechnology Information. Evidence-Based Medical Insight. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6246548/