Surgical Paediatrics: Best Specialist Shortage

Mustafa Çelik

Mustafa Çelik

Magnero Content Team
...
Views
Read Time
Surgical Paediatrics: Best Specialist Shortage
Surgical Paediatrics: Best Specialist Shortage 4

The world is facing a critical shortage of pediatric surgeons. This shortage has a big impact on children’s healthcare. In 2024, the U.S. National Residency Match Program saw a 7.2% drop in pediatric match rates. This left 252 positions unfilled.

So, what is a pediatric surgeon, and why are they in such short supply? A pediatric surgeon is a medical specialist who operates on children. They work with kids from newborns to adolescents. To become one, you need a lot of education and training, including a residency in pediatric surgery.

At Liv Hospital, we’re dedicated to top-notch healthcare. We’re tackling the challenges faced by pediatric surgical specialists. We aim to support and grow the next generation of pediatric surgeons. This way, we ensure kids around the world get the medical care they need.

Key Takeaways

  • The global shortage of pediatric surgeons is a growing concern.
  • The U.S. National Residency Match Program saw a 7.2% drop in pediatric match rates in 2024.
  • Becoming a pediatric surgeon requires extensive education and training.
  • Liv Hospital is committed to delivering world-class healthcare and supporting pediatric surgeons.
  • The shortage of pediatric surgeons has a significant impact on children’s healthcare worldwide.

The Current State of Pediatric Surgery in America

SEP 7229 image 2 LIV Hospital
Surgical Paediatrics: Best Specialist Shortage 5

The field of pediatric surgery in the United States is facing a severe shortage of skilled professionals. This shortage impacts the healthcare delivery for children nationwide.

Statistical Overview of the Shortage

Statistics show a concerning picture. Over 40% of in-hospital pediatric specialist positions are empty in areas like neurology and psychiatry. Pediatric surgery is also facing a big deficit.

Some key statistics include:

  • A big increase in unfilled pediatric surgeon positions in recent years.
  • Pediatric surgical specialists are not evenly distributed, with rural areas being hit hard.
  • The demand for pediatric surgical services is growing due to more children needing specialized care.

Geographic Distribution Challenges

Pediatric surgeons are not evenly spread across the country. Many rural areas lack access to them. Families must travel far for care, causing delays and potentially worsening outcomes.

Key challenges include:

  1. Many rural and underserved areas lack access to pediatric surgical care.
  2. It’s hard to recruit and keep pediatric surgeons in these areas.
  3. New solutions like telemedicine and outreach programs are needed to fill the gap.

Understanding pediatric surgeons’ roles and challenges is key. They undergo long training to care for children from birth to adolescence. The question of how much does a peds surgeon make is often asked. But the financial rewards are just one part of a career that demands dedication and passion.

Understanding the Role of Pediatric Surgeons

SEP 7229 image 3 LIV Hospital
Surgical Paediatrics: Best Specialist Shortage 6

Children need special care when it comes to surgery, and pediatric surgeons are the experts. They play a key role in healthcare, doing complex surgeries on kids.

Specialized Skills Required

Pediatric surgeons get a lot of training to work on kids. They learn about the unique body parts and how they work in children. This is different from adults.

They need special skills for pediatric surgery, including:

  • Being very precise and careful because kids’ organs are smaller.
  • Knowing how to fix birth defects.
  • Staying up-to-date with the latest in pediatric surgery.

Differences from Adult Surgery

Pediatric surgery is different from adult surgery in many ways. Kids’ bodies are growing, and they react differently to surgery than adults do.

Some key differences are:

  1. They need special tools made for their smaller bodies.
  2. They deal with conditions like birth defects that adults don’t have.
  3. They also need to support kids and their families emotionally.

Pediatric surgeons are not just skilled; they are also caring and understand kids’ needs.

“Pediatric surgeons are not just surgeons; they are caregivers who understand the unique needs of children and their families.”

By knowing what a pediatric surgeon does, we see how important and complex their job is in healthcare.

Pediatric Surgeons vs. General Pediatricians

It’s important for parents to know the difference between pediatric surgeons and general pediatricians. Both are key in children’s health, but they do different things. Pediatric surgeons handle surgeries, while general pediatricians focus on regular care.

Scope of Practice Differences

General pediatricians are the first doctors kids see. They do check-ups, give shots, and treat common illnesses. They’re not trained for surgery.

Pediatric surgeons, though, are experts in surgery for kids. They can do complex surgeries. Their training is in-depth and focused on kids’ needs.

Aspect

General Pediatricians

Pediatric Surgeons

Primary Role

Provide primary care, diagnose, and manage common illnesses

Perform surgical procedures for children

Training

Trained in general pediatrics

Specialized training in pediatric surgery

Surgical Capabilities

Do not perform surgery

Trained to perform complex surgical procedures

Common Misconceptions

Many think pediatricians can do surgery. But, general pediatricians do not do surgery. If a child needs surgery, see a pediatric surgeon.

Some also think pediatric surgeons only do surgery. But, they also give care before and after surgery. They work with families to help their kids get better.

To answer a common question: No, general pediatricians do not perform surgery. They’re essential for kids’ health, but surgery is for pediatric surgeons.

The Alarming Decline in Pediatric Surgical Specialists

Pediatric surgical specialists are disappearing fast, as shown by recent match program stats. This loss is big for the healthcare system, mainly because it affects kids’ specialized care.

Recent Match Program Statistics

The U.S. National Residency Match Program saw a 7.2% drop in pediatric matches in 2024. There were 252 spots left empty. This shows a big shortage of pediatric surgeons and the hard time finding these doctors.

Let’s look at the numbers more closely:

Year

Pediatric Match Rate

Unfilled Positions

2023

85.6%

220

2024

78.4%

252

Unfilled Positions and Their Impact

The 252 empty spots in pediatric surgery in 2024 mean a big shortage. This shortage can cause long waits for care, more travel for families, and might harm patient results.

Being a pediatric surgeon needs a lot of education and training. You must finish medical school, then do years of residency and maybe more fellowship. Knowing how long it takes to become a pediatric surgeon and the pediatric surgeon schooling needed is key for those thinking about this career.

If you want to be a pediatric surgeon, you must know the challenges and commitment. The path to becoming one is long and tough. But, it’s very rewarding for those who love helping kids.

The Educational Journey to Become a Pediatric Surgeon

Becoming a pediatric surgeon takes a long time and a lot of hard work. It involves many years of studying and training. This is to make sure future pediatric surgeons have the skills and knowledge they need.

Required Education and Training

First, you need a bachelor’s degree in a science field. Then, you go to medical school for four years to get your M.D. or D.O. After that, you start a general surgery residency, which lasts from five to seven years. You also need to do a pediatric surgery fellowship for one to two years.

The path to becoming a pediatric surgeon is long and tough. It demands a lot of time and effort. You’ll learn a lot about surgery, patient care, and research during your training.

Time Investment Compared to Other Specialties

It takes more than 15 years after high school to become a pediatric surgeon. This is as long as other surgical specialties but longer than many non-surgical ones. For example, a family medicine doctor might finish their training in 7-8 years, while a pediatric surgeon takes nearly twice as long.

  • Undergraduate degree: 4 years
  • Medical school: 4 years
  • General surgery residency: 5-7 years
  • Pediatric surgery fellowship: 1-2 years

The long training shows how complex and specialized pediatric surgery is. It prepares pediatric surgeons to face the unique challenges of their field. They can then give top-notch care to their young patients.

The journey to become a pediatric surgeon is long and challenging. But for those who love working with children, it’s a rewarding path. The hard work and dedication are worth it for the chance to make a difference in kids’ lives.

Financial Realities of Choosing Surgical Paediatrics

Pediatric surgeons face unique financial challenges. These challenges can affect their career choices. Becoming a pediatric surgeon is a long and costly journey.

Compensation Disparities with Adult Specialties

One big financial reality is the pay gap between pediatric and adult surgeons. Pediatric surgeons are highly skilled but often earn less than adult surgeons. This is due to several factors.

  • Pediatric surgeons earn between $400,000 to $600,000 annually.
  • Adult surgeons can make $700,000 to $1 million per year.
  • The pay gap is influenced by procedure complexity, frequency, and insurance reimbursement.

Student Debt Burden vs. Earning Ability

Pediatric surgeons also carry a heavy student debt burden. Medical education is expensive, and pediatric surgery training adds to the cost. This means they often graduate with a lot of debt.

Key statistics include:

  1. Medical students typically have $200,000 to $300,000 in debt.
  2. Pediatric surgery training adds years and costs to their education.
  3. While pediatric surgeons earn well, their income may not cover debt quickly.

These financial realities are important when discussing the shortage of pediatric surgeons. The financial hurdles can discourage some from entering this vital field. This makes the shortage worse.

Maldistribution of Pediatric Surgical Care

The way pediatric surgeons are spread out is not fair. This unfair spread affects how well children get care. It makes it hard for kids in some places to get the surgery they need.

Urban vs. Rural Access Disparities

There’s a big problem with getting to pediatric surgeons in cities versus rural areas. Cities usually have more surgeons, but rural areas have very few. This means kids in rural areas have to travel far to get the surgery they need.

Rural areas find it hard to keep pediatric surgeons. This is because they don’t have enough money, pay surgeons less, and lack support. Families in these areas face big challenges in getting their kids the care they need.

Regional Variations in Specialist Availability

How many pediatric surgeons are in a region also affects care. Some places have lots of surgeons, while others have very few. This depends on how many people live there, the local economy, and if there are medical schools.

Regional healthcare policies can help fix these problems. They can offer help like forgiving loans, moving costs, and other support. This can encourage surgeons to work in areas that really need them.

By understanding why pediatric surgeons are not spread out evenly, we can start fixing these problems. We can make sure every child gets the surgery they need, no matter where they live.

Patient Impact: Consequences of the Shortage

The shortage of pediatric surgeons is causing problems for families. They face longer wait times and have to travel more. This shortage affects more than just healthcare, impacting families’ daily lives and well-being.

Extended Wait Times for Specialized Care

One big issue is the long wait for specialized care. Families may wait weeks or months for surgery. A study shows wait times can be 4 to 12 weeks, sometimes up to 6 months. This delay causes children to suffer longer and parents to worry more.

A well-known pediatric surgeon, says, “Long wait times hurt the child and the family’s quality of life.”

“The wait for our child’s surgery was agonizing. We had to wait for three months, and it was a very stressful period for our family.”

Travel Burdens on Families Seeking Treatment

Families also face big travel challenges. They must travel far to find pediatric surgeons. This is time-consuming and expensive. The cost of travel, staying away, and lost work can be too much for many.

A study by the Children’s Hospital Association shows families travel over 100 miles. Some go as far as 500 miles for care.

The effects of travel on families are huge. They must balance their child’s needs with work and family duties. This forces families to make tough choices. Understanding these challenges helps us find ways to help.

Subspecialty Vacancies in Pediatric Medicine

The need for pediatric care is growing, but there aren’t enough subspecialists, like in neurology and psychiatry. This shortage affects many parts of pediatric medicine.

Critical Gaps in Neurology and Psychiatry

More than 40% of in-hospital pediatric specialist spots are empty in areas like neurology and psychiatry. This shortage can harm children’s health. Timely and specialized care are key for treating complex conditions.

Without enough specialists in pediatric neurology and psychiatry, many children don’t get the care they need. This can lead to long-term health problems. For example, neurological disorders need precise diagnosis and treatment, which can be delayed or not good enough without enough specialists.

  • Delayed diagnosis and treatment of neurological disorders
  • Increased burden on existing specialists
  • Potential for misdiagnosis or inadequate care

Emergency Medicine Shortfalls

Emergency medicine is also facing big shortfalls. Pediatric emergency departments need specialists who know how to handle children’s emergency needs. Without enough pediatric emergency medicine specialists, there can be overcrowding, longer wait times, and lower quality care.

Some big challenges in pediatric emergency medicine include:

  1. Managing complex and acute conditions in children
  2. Providing timely and effective care in high-pressure situations
  3. Coordinating with other specialists for complete care

We must tackle these subspecialty vacancies to make sure children get the specialized care they need. We need new solutions and strategies to attract and keep specialists in these key areas.

Systemic Factors Contributing to the Shortage

Several systemic factors are causing a shortage of pediatric surgeons in the U.S. The mix of healthcare funding and insurance challenges affects the availability of pediatric surgical care.

Healthcare Funding Priorities

Healthcare funding is key in shaping pediatric surgical care. Limited federal support for pediatric surgery programs slows the growth of new specialists. We need to rethink how we allocate resources to support pediatric surgical training and expertise.

  • Limited funding for pediatric surgery research and training programs
  • Prioritization of other medical specialties over pediatric surgery
  • Inadequate support for infrastructure in pediatric surgical care

Pediatric surgeons need advanced training and a supportive environment. Yet, this environment is often underfunded.

Insurance Reimbursement Challenges

Insurance reimbursement issues also impact pediatric surgeons. Low reimbursement rates for pediatric surgeries make it hard for hospitals and surgeons to keep practices afloat.

“Reimbursement rates for surgical procedures are often lower than the actual cost of care, placing a significant burden on hospitals and surgeons who specialize in pediatric care.”

The financial pressure from low reimbursement can discourage pediatric surgeons from continuing their work. This adds to the shortage.

The question of how much does a peds surgeon make is important. Pediatric surgeons are among the highest-paid, but their pay doesn’t always match the complexity of their work.

We must tackle these systemic issues to ensure skilled pediatric surgeons for the future. By addressing these challenges, we can build a healthcare system that supports the specialized care children need.

The Work-Life Balance Challenge

Pediatric surgery is a high-stakes field that makes it hard to balance work and life. Pediatric surgeons often have demanding schedules. This can affect their personal and family life.

On-Call Demands and Burnout

Pediatric surgeons work long hours and face high stress. This can lead to burnout. Being on call 24/7 can disrupt their personal time and rest.

Burnout is a big problem in medicine, and it hits surgeons hard. The emotional and physical strain of working with sick kids can harm pediatric surgeons. It affects their well-being and job happiness.

Family Planning Considerations

Family planning is also affected by the demands of pediatric surgery. Long hours, night shifts, and weekend work make it hard for pediatric surgeons to manage family life.

The need to perform well and the emotional demands of the job can influence family planning. We need to think about how these factors affect pediatric surgeons. We should find ways to help them achieve a better work-life balance.

Understanding these challenges helps us create a better work environment for pediatric surgeons. This way, they can give their best care to patients while taking care of themselves.

Comparing International Approaches to Pediatric Surgery

Across the globe, pediatric surgery practices vary widely. Each country has its own way of handling surgical needs for kids. By looking at these differences, we can learn valuable lessons and improve care for children everywhere.

Global Best Practices

Some countries have made big strides in pediatric surgery. For example, they’ve set up special centers for kids’ surgery. This has led to better results because of the focus on expertise and resources.

Advanced tech like robotic surgery and telemedicine is also being used worldwide. These tools help make surgeries more precise and reach more kids, even in hard-to-reach places.

Country

Approach to Pediatric Surgery

Notable Outcomes

United States

Varied, with both general and specialized pediatric surgical centers

Advanced training programs for pediatric surgeons

United Kingdom

Centralized in specialized centers

Improved surgical outcomes due to concentrated expertise

Australia

Combination of metropolitan and regional centers with telemedicine support

Enhanced access to care for rural populations

Lessons from Healthcare Systems Abroad

Looking at healthcare systems around the world offers insights. For instance, some countries offer financial help to doctors who choose pediatric surgery. This encourages more to pursue this field.

International teamwork and training are also key. They help pediatric surgeons improve their skills and share best practices. This understanding helps tackle the worldwide shortage of these specialists.

To become a pediatric surgeon, one needs a lot of education and hands-on experience. Training methods vary globally. Yet, there’s a growing push for worldwide standards. This ensures pediatric surgeons can provide top-notch care, no matter where they work.

Innovative Solutions: Liv Hospital’s Approach

Liv Hospital is dedicated to top-notch healthcare. We tackle the shortage of pediatric surgeons with a unique strategy. This strategy attracts the best talent and promotes excellence in pediatric surgery.

Multidisciplinary Care Models

At Liv Hospital, we use multidisciplinary care models. These models bring together experts from different fields for our young patients. Pediatric surgeons work with neonatologists, radiologists, and anesthesiologists for the best results.

Our teams tackle complex cases with a holistic approach. They consider each child’s physical, emotional, and psychological needs. This teamwork reduces the workload on surgeons and boosts care quality.

International Competitiveness Strategies

Liv Hospital attracts top pediatric surgeons with international competitiveness strategies. We offer great pay, growth chances, and a supportive work environment. This encourages innovation and excellence.

We also partner with famous institutions and attend global conferences. This keeps us updated on pediatric surgery advancements. It attracts international talent and shares knowledge worldwide.

Liv Hospital is making a big difference in pediatric surgery. We’re committed to bettering care and giving our patients the best outcomes.

Federal and State Policy Interventions

Federal and state governments are working hard to solve the shortage of pediatric surgeons. They are using policy to increase the number of pediatric surgeons. This will help more children get the care they need.

One big strategy is to offer financial help to those who want to be pediatric surgeons. This includes loan forgiveness programs to ease the financial stress on future pediatric surgeons.

Loan Forgiveness Programs

Loan forgiveness programs are a big part of these efforts. They give financial relief to medical students who promise to work as pediatric surgeons in areas that need them most. This can be for a certain number of years.

  • Programs like the National Health Service Corps (NHSC) offer a lot of loan forgiveness for those who work in high-need areas.
  • States, like those in rural areas, also have their own programs to help pediatric surgeons work there.

These programs make it easier for medical students to choose a career in pediatric surgery. They help reduce the financial stress of medical school.

Funding for Pediatric Training Programs

There’s also more money for training programs for pediatric surgeons. This money helps create strong programs that can train more doctors and surgeons.

Some important parts of this funding are:

  1. Grants for research to improve outcomes in pediatric surgery.
  2. Support for training with simulators to improve surgical skills.
  3. Funding for international training to give doctors a wider experience.

These efforts are key to solving the shortage of pediatric surgeons. By giving financial help and supporting education, we can draw more people to this important field. This way, children everywhere can get the care they need.

The Future of Pediatric Surgery: Technological Advances

Pediatric surgery is changing fast, thanks to new technologies. These advancements are making surgeries better and easier for kids. It’s clear that technology will keep shaping this field.

Telemedicine Applications

Telemedicine is a big step forward in pediatric surgery. It lets pediatric surgeons talk to patients from afar. This makes getting care easier and safer, which is great during times like the COVID-19 pandemic.

Telemedicine isn’t just for first meetings. Many pediatric surgeons use it for check-ups and to keep an eye on how patients are doing. This makes things more convenient for patients and helps surgeons keep a closer eye on recovery.

Robotic and Minimally Invasive Innovations

Robotic surgery and other small procedures are changing pediatric surgery. These methods let surgeons do complex tasks with more accuracy and less harm. This means kids can heal faster and have less scarring.

Robotic systems are making a big difference in pediatric surgery. They help with tricky operations that were hard or impossible before. For example, they’re used for delicate work in the urinary or digestive systems.

Looking ahead, we can expect even more improvements in small procedures. These might include using artificial intelligence and machine learning to make surgeries even more precise.

As we look to the future, it’s important to understand the role of pediatric surgeons. They’re not just skilled in old ways of surgery. They’re also learning to use new technologies to give kids the best care possible.

Recruitment Strategies for the Next Generation

To ensure a sustainable future for pediatric surgery, we need to focus on effective recruitment strategies. Attracting talented medical professionals to this specialized field requires a thorough approach. This starts early in their educational journey.

Early Exposure Programs

Early exposure programs are key in introducing medical students to pediatric surgery. By adding pediatric surgery rotations to medical school curricula, we spark interest and enthusiasm. These programs offer hands-on experience, letting students work with experienced pediatric surgeons.

Key components of successful early exposure programs include:

  • Hands-on surgical experience
  • Mentorship from experienced pediatric surgeons
  • Opportunities for research and academic participation

Mentorship and Pipeline Development

Mentorship is vital in shaping future pediatric surgeons. Experienced surgeons offer guidance, support, and insights. This helps shape the next generation of specialists. Pipeline development programs create a structured path for students, from medical school to residency and beyond.

Effective mentorship involves:

  1. Regular meetings and feedback sessions
  2. Opportunities for research collaboration
  3. Guidance on career development and specialization

By implementing these strategies, we can attract and retain talented individuals in pediatric surgery. This ensures a bright future for this vital specialty.

Conclusion: Addressing the Pediatric Surgeon Shortage

The shortage of pediatric surgeons is a big problem. It needs a mix of solutions to fix it. At Liv Hospital, we know kids need special care and we’re working hard to help.

We understand the challenges pediatric surgeons face. These include long education, financial issues, and balancing work and life. We’re finding ways to attract and keep the best surgeons for kids.

We’re using new care models and technology to help. This includes teams working together and using telemedicine and robotic surgery. These steps improve care and make it easier to reach more kids, even in hard-to-reach places.

We’re teaming up with others in healthcare to make sure kids get the care they need. Our goal is to provide top-notch healthcare and support for patients from around the world. We’re dedicated to solving the shortage of pediatric surgeons.

FAQ

What is a pediatric surgeon?

A pediatric surgeon is a doctor who specializes in surgery for kids. They work with children from birth to teens. They fix many health problems that need surgery.

How long does it take to become a pediatric surgeon?

It takes a lot of time to become a pediatric surgeon. You need at least 15 years of education and training after high school. This includes medical school and residency.

Do pediatricians do surgery?

No, pediatricians don’t do surgery. They take care of kids’ health but don’t do complex surgeries. Pediatric surgeons are trained for that.

What do pediatric surgeons do?

Pediatric surgeons do many surgeries on kids. They fix birth defects, injuries, and diseases that need surgery.

How much do pediatric surgeons make?

Pediatric surgeons’ pay varies. It depends on where they work, how long they’ve been practicing, and their specialty. They often face financial challenges, like lower pay than adult surgeons and high student loans.

What are the differences between pediatric and adult surgery?

Surgery for kids is different from adult surgery. Kids’ bodies are smaller and changing. Pediatric surgeons need special training to work with these differences.

How do I become a pediatric surgeon?

To be a pediatric surgeon, you need a lot of education. First, you go to medical school. Then, you do a residency in pediatric surgery. You might also do a fellowship for more training.

What is the role of pediatric surgeons in children’s healthcare?

Pediatric surgeons are key in kids’ healthcare. They do surgeries for many health issues. They work with other doctors to give kids the best care.

Are there global best practices in pediatric surgery?

Yes, there are global best practices in pediatric surgery. Hospitals can follow these to improve care. These include working together, new surgery techniques, and new ways to care for patients.

What are the challenges faced by pediatric surgeons?

Pediatric surgeons face many challenges. There’s a shortage of them, and they’re not spread out evenly. They also deal with money issues, finding a good work-life balance, and systemic problems like funding and insurance.

How can the shortage of pediatric surgeons be addressed?

To fix the shortage, we need many solutions. We need policies like loan forgiveness, more funding for training, and ways to attract new surgeons. Liv Hospital has shown innovative ways to solve these problems.

National Center for Biotechnology Information. Evidence-Based Medical Insight. Retrieved from


References

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11273707

Trusted Worldwide
30
Years of
Experience
30 Years Badge

With patients from across the globe, we bring over three decades of medical

LIV Hospital Expert Healthcare
Patient Reviews
Reviews from 9,651
4,9

Get a Free Quote

Response within 2 hours during business hours

Clinics/branches
Was this content helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve.
What did you like?
Share more details about your experience.
You must give consent to continue.

Thank you!

Your feedback has been submitted successfully. Your input is valuable in helping us improve.

Our Doctors

MD. Seyhan Çavuş

MD. Seyhan Çavuş

Op. MD. Kübra Karakolcu

Op. MD. Kübra Karakolcu

Assoc. Prof. MD. Çağdaş Gökhun Özmerdiven

Assoc. Prof. MD. Çağdaş Gökhun Özmerdiven

Asst. Prof. MD. Alaaddin Aydın

Asst. Prof. MD. Alaaddin Aydın

Spec. MD. Hilal Yüksel Aksakal

Spec. MD. Hilal Yüksel Aksakal

Spec. MD. Elmir İsrafilov

Spec. MD. Elmir İsrafilov

Diet. Özgenaz Kazan

Diet. Özgenaz Kazan

Assoc. Prof. MD. Ali Erhan Özdemirel

Assoc. Prof. MD. Ali Erhan Özdemirel

Assoc. Prof. MD. Ahmet Anıl Şahin

Prof. MD. Nihat Demir

Prof. MD. Nihat Demir

Asst. Prof. MD. Rıza Asil

Asst. Prof. MD. Rıza Asil

Assoc. Prof. MD. Çiğdem İleri Doğan

Assoc. Prof. MD. Çiğdem İleri Doğan

Your Comparison List (you must select at least 2 packages)